A recent topic in a technical discussion group I belong to has been the state of education in the United States. Members have been discussing this based on their own experiences (as children) in the system, as well as their perceptions as parents of children in the system today. An (obvious) conclusion has been that schools differ widely.
One member posted a pointer to a rather distressing article, written by the late Richard Fenyman, regarding his experience on a school textbook review committee. Although the article was written in 1965, the Textbook League (established in 1989 to support the creation and acceptance of sound schoolbooks) claims that Feynman;'s points are just as relevant today.
In 1964 the eminent physicist Richard Feynman served on the State of California's Curriculum Commission and saw how the Commission chose math textbooks for use in California's public schools. In his acerbic memoir of that experience, titled "Judging Books by Their Covers," Feynman analyzed the Commission's idiotic method of evaluating books, and he described some of the tactics employed by schoolbook salesmen who wanted the Commission to adopt their shoddy products. "Judging Books by Their Covers" appeared as a chapter in "Surely You're Joking, Mr. Feynman!" -- Feynman's autobiographical book that was published in 1985 by W.W. Norton & Company.
To introduce a series of articles about corruption in schoolbook-adoption proceedings, we present here (with permission from W.W. Norton & Company) an extended excerpt from Feynman's narrative.
As our "Annals of Corruption" series unfolds, readers will see that Feynman's account is as timely now as it was when he wrote it. State adoption proceedings still are pervaded by sham, malfeasance and ludicrous incompetence, and they still reflect cozy connections between state agencies and schoolbook companies.
Having read Feynman's essay, I can only say